Showing posts with label EFSF. Show all posts
Showing posts with label EFSF. Show all posts

Monday, January 16, 2012

Another shoe drops: EFSF downgraded



This was fast. On the Martin Luther King day, a holiday in the US, the US-based S&P downgradedthe European Financial Stability Facility (EFSF) from AAA to AA+, even sooner than I expected. 

Just last Friday Standard & Poor downgraded 9 European economies by one or two notches, and had a negative outlook for every EU economy, except Germany. I wrote that these downgrades would inevitably result in the downgrade of the EFSF and contribute to a vicious cycle of negative feedback, because lower ratings ultimately require more money for bailouts, and also deplete the state coffers.

Nicolas Sarkozy desperately tried to avoid the downgrade of France, before the upcoming elections, which he is likely to lose. After the loss of the coveted rating he said "my conviction is that it changes nothing". 

The chief executive of EFSF, Klaus Regling, said: "The downgrade to 'AA+' by only one credit agency will not reduce EFSF's lending capacity of 440 billion euros". Is this an example of the "too big to fail" mentality, or at least "too big to be affected by a downgrade of only one of the three ratings agencies". Neither. Regling added "EFSF has sufficient means to fulfill its commitments under current and potential future adjustment programs until the ESM becomes operational in July 2012". The previous two years averaged transfers of about 300 billion euros from the EU core to the periphery. It seems that Klaus is merely saying that 400 billion should be enough this year.

Sarkozy's motives for a sudden change of attitude for manipulating the public opinion are transparent. Regling's statement is no less disingenuous, because it attempts to hide a long term problem behind 'solution by redistribution', a short-term and short-sighted strategy. 

Also today Germany refused to boost the funding of EFSF, just as the bankruptcy of Greece this spring is beginning to look inevitable. Germany was pushing private creditors to accept new bonds the planned swap to carry that would increase the banks' effective losses to 75 percent. Those private lenders recently turned down the offer to 'voluntarily' accept 50 percent losses. Klaus Regling, as an major economist and a German, cannot be unaware how this very day his country's policies are making Greek default a certainty, barring some miracle. Greek default will have a devastating effect on the French banks, while Germany hold relatively little Greek sovereign bonds. In addition Germany is benefiting politically as its neighbors and competitors in Europe weaken economically. However, is Europe ready to accept this soft, insidious form of German hegemony?

Friday, January 13, 2012

Facing the facts: The great EU credit downgrade

Fitch ratings agency said about a month ago they will review France's rating this coming year, but they were beaten to the punch by the S&P. The inevitable downgrade happened even sooner than expected, and in addition to France, with its heavy exposure to Greek debt and significant deficits, S&P downgraded 8 other European nations. S&P lowered its long-term rating on Cyprus, Italy, Portugal and Spain by two notches, and cut its rating on Austria, France, Malta, Slovakia and Slovenia by one notch. The move puts highly indebted Italy on the same BBB+ level as Kazakhstan and pushed Portugal debt into junk status. The US-based credit-rating agency affirmed the current long-term ratings for Belgium, Estonia, Finland, Germany, Ireland, Luxembourg and the Netherlands. S&P put all 14 of the above euro-zone nations — Austria, Belgium, Cyprus, Estonia, Finland, France, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, Malta, the Netherlands, Portugal, Slovenia, and Spain — on "negative" outlook for a possible further downgrade. Only Germany was the retained its AAA rating and a stable outlook.

The downgrade has been precipitated by the breakdown of talks between Greece and its creditors over a debt swap seen as crucial to avert a Greek default. Officials said more talks are likely next week, but also mentioned that there's no agreement on any of the issues involved in a voluntary 'haircut', which is a nice euphemism for being fleeced 40-60% on investments. Chances of Greek default in March are significant, so it's understandable that rating agencies will want to get ahead of the curve.

"Today's rating actions are primarily driven by our assessment that the policy initiatives that have been taken by European policy makers in recent weeks may be insufficient to fully address ongoing systemic stresses in the euro zone," S&P said in a press release announcing the downgrade.

S&P is more diplomatic than yours truly. I simply said that the European plan is a smoke screen. This is wishful thinking mascaraing as a policy. No responsible engineer can build a bridge based on hope alone, without adequate calculation. It's unlikely that there's a total lack of understanding for the fundamentals that are apparent even to a layman like me, therefore, I said the leadership (Merkozy and Co.) have been simply lying to the public. Austerity and budget discipline alone were not sufficient to fight the debt crisis and risked becoming self-defeating, the ratings agency said. How much are these people paid? I wrote two months ago: "The idea that austerity alone, or in combination with stricter rules, as Angela Merkel wishes to do, could solve EU's problems, stemming from trade imbalances, is a lie." Almost that far back I also wrote blogging ahead of the curve about the huge cuts such a plan would entail, and the lack of political will for such enormous cuts. I pointed out the inherent weakness of the French AAA credit rating in another article, after UK dissed new EU rules, provoking French comments on the weakness of the British economy, and unsustainability of its credit rating. The goal is not to be self-congratulatory, but merely to point out; once again, the unfolding events were so easily predictable, that the only way to deny them is either total incompetence (which I don't believe) or outright misrepresentation.

The first rule of suicide pact is to lie early and often. Experts agree this is a suicide pact: the chief economist of Commerzbank, Joerg Kraemer, said that the consequence of the downgrade is that the European Financial Stability Facility (EFSF) also will lose its triple-A rating. "That may irritate markets in the short term but wouldn't be a big problem in a world where the U.S. and Japan also don't have a triple-A rating anymore. Triple-A is a dying species," he said.

This is exactly what I mean by the suicide pact in general: a horrible decision taken jointly. This is why Obama's presidency is so favorable for Europe: by following EU's inane pattern of overspending the US has dramatically increased its debts and deficits. European troubles will have been much worse if US had act together, because it would make investments in EU less attractive, and greatly increase its borrowing costs.

The consequence of the downgrade, which was already partially priced into the borrowing rates of soverign nations, is likely to result in additional increase of these costs. The AAA rating is crucial for the functioning of the EFSF, and one of the consequences of downgrade is the need to pump additional money into the bailout fund. At the same time, the downgrades of banks make triggered forced selling of sovereign debt resulting in increased borrowing costs of these nations.

EU monetary affairs commissioner Olli Rehn called S&P’s decisions “inconsistent” and suggested they ignored the “decisive action” taken by the eurozone to commit to budget, structural and banking-sector reforms, and to a more powerful rescue fund.

The German government said the Eurozone’s determination to overcome the debt crisis stood “beyond question”, echoing the sentiments expressed by other countries. At the same time, in Frankfurt, the ECB criticized the draft of a new fiscal discipline treaty for the euro area, saying that the latest version amounted to “a substantial watering-down” of tough deficit levels that could allow “easy circumvention of the [deficit] rule” by struggling governments.

So, there you have it. The leaders are proclaiming piety, while their bean counters are noting that the proposed strict rules are simply wishful thinking. Lies, actually.